Today's Wisdom

Showing posts with label classical education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label classical education. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 4, 2015

Review of The Conversation by Leigh A. Bortins

Classical Conversations has given the Schoolhouse Review Crew the opportunity to review Leigh A. Bortins' latest book, The Conversation.  

This book is broken up into two parts.  Part 1 is "High School at Home" and Part 2 is "The Rhetorical Arts."  

Part 1

This section gives you insights on how your day might be scheduled, answers questions on socialization, and helps combat some of the inadequacies parents often feel as they head into the high school years.  Rhetoric is also defined in this part of the book and continued all though out.  The classical model contains three stages of progression as we learn something new - grammar, dialectic, and rhetoric.  The grammar and dialectic stages often go along with elementary and middle school ages although depending upon the child and what is being learned, the stages can hit at different ages.

Often times though, once your child has reached high school age, they have memorized facts, learned the vocabulary, asked the questions, researched, and analyzed other's ideas.  So, after that they are ready to move on to sharing what they've learned and presenting their own ideas (aka The Rhetoric Stage).  

This sections also defines the five cannons of the rhetoric which are Invention, Arrangement, Elocution, Memory, and Delivery.  There is a great chart inside the book that greatly breaks each of these canons down by giving you a question and action for each one.  

Part 2

This is where "the meat" of your book takes place.  In the chapters of this section, Ms. Bortins guides you along 9 subject areas that your high schooler is most likely to encounter by giving you examples of conversations, questions to ask, and projects that she has seen work in her own environment.  Subject areas include Reading, Speech and Debate, Writing, Science, Math, Government and Economics, History, Latin and Foreign Languages, and Fine Arts.  If you are familiar with The Core or The Question, this section follows along those same formats but is directed completely to the rhetoric stage.   She also has included games you can play showing that conversing doesn't have to be boring but can be fun too.

Classical Conversations Review

Ms. Bortins ends the book answering questions about graduation that she has received from parents and shares great wisdom and encouragement for parents who are seeking to educate their children at home.  My favorite quote was, "Education is not about the individual but about the family of God building His kingdom on earth.  It is about legacy and heritage."  I could not agree more.  That is what I want my children's education to look like in the end.  

Our homeschool is what I would consider a eclectic Christian classical family.  With my oldest, we did not start a classical education until later in his middle school years and I can really see the difference of starting at the beginning versus starting late.  However, I do not think it is ever too late and Ms. Bortins agrees.  I, myself, am learning just as much as my children!  If the individual has the desire to learn, that is all it takes.  

Even if you do not define your homeschool style as entirely or even partially classical, I believe this is a great read for all parents.  It gives you great insight on having rich conversations with your child once they reach the rhetoric stage (high school).  It also provides practical tips on staying the course of educating at home during the high school years which is needed for all! I am so grateful for those who have gone before me and are willing to share, encourage, and inspire through their own journeys.  You will find all of that plus practical steps to implement in your homeschool as well as great questions to get you started with those rich conversations right away!

Find out more about Classical Conversations and The Conversation by visiting the following:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/classicalconversations
Twitter: https://twitter.com/classicalconv
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/classicalconv/
Google+: https://plus.google.com/117616164250444350670/posts
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/ClassicalConv

Classical Conversations Review
Crew Disclaimer


Wednesday, June 3, 2015

Review of The Book of Ancient Romans Set

Memoria Press Review

Today's review is from Memoria Press who has brought back into publication some history books written by Dorothy Mills in the 1920's. They have added in some illustrations to update the books a little but overall they are the same history books that children would have learned from many years ago. The set I reviewed was The Book of the Ancient Romans Set. This classical history set is recommended for middle school grades but can also be used by high schoolers.  

Memoria Press Review
The set currently sells for $39.95 and includes physical products of the student text, student guide, and teacher manual.  
The student text takes you through the beginnings of Rome, the various lines of kings, the rise of the greatness of Rome, her triumphs as well as her decline and eventual fall. Mrs. Mills includes quotes from ancient historians such as Livy, Polybius, Appian and more. The illustrations and maps are in black and white like the ones you see below. See a Text Sample.

The student guide helps the student find the important components of each lesson with several sections including facts to know, vocabulary, comprehension questions, and activity questions including a timeline and map activities. This is a consumable book. See a Student Sample page.

The teacher manual is an exact replica of the student guide containing your answer key which really came in handy for us. The teacher manual also includes the the 5 tests and final exam along with those keys. See a Teacher Sample page.

How We Used This In Our Homeschool 

I had my middle schooler, Stephen, who is in 8th grade, work on this course. There are 26 lessons plus 5 reviews, 5 tests, and a final exam. There is no guidance on how to break the course up so we focused on completing 1 lesson per week for 3-4 days per week. Stephen started out independently working on the course himself and we went over the study guide together. He was comprehending what he was reading but often times found the vocabulary frustrating and hard to get through. So, by week 3, we began to work on the reading portion together as well. It helped him for me to read aloud some of the text and I too found some of the vocabulary and reading difficult. 
 
Lessons ranged from 2 pages of text reading to 17 pages so we adjusted our original plan of 1 lesson per week when needed. I would never assign more than 5 pages to read in one day hoping to keep the frustration levels low and comprehension levels high. This is not an easy course but we did find it stretching our vocabulary and pushing us both out of our comfort zones. 

I could definitely see where this could be used as a high school course as well considering the vocabulary and activities that are made available. The map illustrations were some of our favorites parts.


Check out the Table of Contents page and sample pages to see if this might be a good fit for your family. 

You can also find Memoria Press on Facebook and Twitter. They have lots of classical Christian curriculum choices available including Logic & Rhetoric, History, Latin, and more.

Click the banner below to see what my crewmates thought of The Book of the Ancient Romans Set, the Famous Men of Rome Set, and the Latina Christiana I Complete Set.


Memoria Press Review

Crew Disclaimer

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

Review - Old Western Culture: The Greeks

Roman Roads Media Review
Roman Roads Media has produced a homeschool curriculum that I was extremely excited about trying!  Old Western Culture: The Greeks is a full year course that explores history, theology, philosophy, poetry, and art from the perspective of the greatest works of influential literature of the Western world. The term "Old Western Culture" is a term coined by C.S. Lewis to describe the fabric of ideas that shaped Western Civilization.  

The whole 4 year course is still being completed and when finished will be:

Year 1: The Greeks
Greeks: Epics
Greeks: Drama & Lyric
Greeks: Histories
Greeks: Philosophers

Year 2: The Romans
Romans: The Aeneid
Romans: Historians
Romans: Christianity
Romans: Nicea

Year 3: Christendom
Coming 2015

Year 4: Early Moderns
Coming 2016

The course is available in DVD and online streaming formats.  I was sent Year 1: The Greeks, which is a full year course.  I received the self paced online streaming format.  I was also sent a DVD of Unit 1: The Epics so that I could try out both formats.

DVD Course - $224 + $7 shipping fee (USA)
Self Paced Online Streaming Course - $199 (on sale as of this writing)

Both the DVD and Online Streaming courses include Digital copies of the Student Workbooks but you can purchase a physical copy for $48 (includes 4 workbooks - 1 for each unit). 

Both formats and extras can be purchased at the Roman Roads Media website.

The full one year Classical Christian Homeschool course is broken down into 4 units with each unit lasting 9 weeks.  

Roman Roads Media Review

The 4 Units are:
The Epics - covers The Iliad and The Odyssey
Drama and Lyric - covers a collection of Greek plays and poetry
The Histories - covers the works of Herodotus, Thucydides, and Xenophon
The Philosophers - covers selected works of Plato and Aristotle

Each Unit Includes:
  • 12 Lessons with Video Lectures for each Lesson (48 for the full year)
  • PDF Student Workbook with comprehension questions
  • PDF Answer Keys
  • 9 week suggested schedule
  • All required texts in etext form (PDF and Kindle)
  • Guide to the Art booklet (online streaming gives you a PDF version and DVD version includes a booklet for you in each DVD)
  • 2 exams with teacher guide and answer key for each unit


You can find an outline of the 12 Lessons in each Unit here. Each Lesson is approximately 30 minutes each.


Prerequisites required from the website...

Old Western Culture is intended for mature and discerning students. We recommend this course for ages 14 and up. The course will deal with mature themes such as paganism, sexual immorality, battle scenes (mostly in actual reading), and classical paintings. Old Western Culture is meant to equip your child with a Biblical lens from which to process these themes. We assume your child has a working knowledge of the Bible and basic Christian doctrine. Advanced readers will have an advantage since the reading load is relatively heavy. 

My Thoughts

I chose to go through this curriculum myself and test drive it before introducing it to my children.  

We follow what I call an eclectic classical homeschool style. I never experienced reading any of the Great Books in school so I wanted to offer that advantage to my children.  I must admit though, they intimidate me greatly!  I have a hard time understanding them and therefore teaching them is even more intimidating.  My children know my homeschool philosophy is that we NEVER stop learning so just because I don't know something doesn't mean we cannot learn about it.  That is often when we begin our journey of learning together!  I was hoping that this curriculum would be just the aid I was looking for.  I was looking for something to help me teach my children while reading some of the Great Books.  

The student questions in the online streaming format were multiple choice questions while the ones included in the PDF with the DVD I received were writing the answer out.  I answered the multiple choice questions in the online streaming format and had difficulty so I didn't even try the ones on the DVD PDF!  

I found that the suggested 9 week schedule included was not too heavy of a course load considering you are working towards 2 full year credits for high school.  For comprehension reasons however, I would have to take the course at a slower pace than suggested which is truly the beauty of homeschooling.
While this curriculum did contain what I was looking for - someone to teach my children and myself more about the influential works of art from a Biblical worldview, it was often times above my head.  Wes Callihan is a master story teller with so much knowledge and there is no doubt that he has researched what he is teaching thoroughly.  I had to watch several of the lectures over even to answer some of the questions myself.  This curriculum is recommended for ages 14 and up.  I felt like it could pass as a college course!  With that being said, I can tell you that I did learn so much from this curriculum.  I would need to slow down the schedule for myself so I am almost certain I would have to do the same for my children.  I do not think my 8th grader or 11th grader would be ready for this curriculum as of yet.  Neither are advanced readers. 

Having said that, I do think this would be a great curriculum to go through together as a family.  Mr. Callihan speaks so eloquently on these topics and always keeps a Christ-centered approach. We can learn much from past mistakes and see clearly where God was left out - much chaos reigned.  Teaching that to the next generation is not an option - it's a must for Christians.  To approach such pagan instruments is often difficult so this is a valuable resource for those intimidated by the subjects like I am.  

Here is a book list of the works covered (again these are included in digital etext versions) but you also can purchase your physical copy as well.  You can find the links to these books here.

THE EPICS BOOK LIST:
- The Iliad
- The Odyssey

DRAMA AND LYRIC BOOK LIST:
- Aeschylus (The Oresteia)
- Sophocles (Oedipus the King and Oedipus at Colonus)
- Aristophanes (The Frogs and The Clouds)
- Eurpipides (The Medea and The Trojan Women) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Sappho (various poems) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Pindar (collection of Odes) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Theocritus (Idyls I, VI, VII, and XI) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Hesiod (Works and Days) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Quintus of Smyrna (The Fall of Troy) included in Roman Roads Reader
- Apollonius of Rhodes (The Argonautica) included in Roman Roads Reader

THE HISTORIES BOOK LIST:
- The Landmark Herodotus: The Histories
- The Landmark Thucydides
- Xenophon: The Persian Expedition

THE PHILOSOPHERS BOOK LIST:
- Plato: Six Greek Dialogues
- The Basic Works of Aristotle 


You can also find several samples here so you can decide for yourself if this curriculum is right for you.

Other Places To Find Romans Road Media

See what my fellow crewmates thought of this curriculum and others offered from Roman Roads Media by clicking the banner below.

Click to read Crew Reviews

Crew Disclaimer